Into the Fire

Passionate thoughts about the world of writing and the Power of God

                Desire-clipart-my-wants-needs-vs-yours-selfish-desires-signs-several-colorful-arrow-street-words-i-want-you-want-want-31863843

What do you want from the review of a novel? How do you want the opinion of the novel expressed? What do you expect from a review? I think it's safe to say none of us want spoilers – yet so often they appear. And I admit it's difficult with some books to write a review without giving away portions of the story. 

I want a simple opinion of why a reader enjoyed a book. If they didn't care for it, I want a brief explanation as to why. I really don't want demeaning sarcasm or attacks on the author's writing. I understand an individual not liking a book – my review list here would be much longer if I'd decided to review the novels I didn't particularly like. 

So tell me what you want, expect, and/or like in a novel review? 

 

Father, thank you for all the readers, all the lovers of stories. Thank you for inspiring those that honor you. Every good and perfect gift comes down from you. Apart from you, I can do nothing. In the Name of Jesus, Amen.

Posted in

3 responses to “From reviews . . .”

  1. Brenda S. Anderson Avatar

    As you said, a simple why they liked–or didn’t like–the book. No spoilers. No rehashing the the story line. No snarkiness. I think that’s the most helpful for readers.

    Like

  2. Debra Avatar
    Debra

    I like to know the genre, the setting, the pace, sad or light-hearted, whether it’s a cliff-hanger and if there’s profanity or explicit scenes. I think your reviews are great. They have been so helpful to me in finding authors and stories.

    Like

  3. Nicole Petrino-Salter Avatar

    Yay! Deb and Bren, so good to know. Thank you both for your comments.

    Like

Leave a comment