Into the Fire

Passionate thoughts about the world of writing and the Power of God

So. Here’s your chance to analyze, comment on, or consider whether or not you like formulaic genre writing. Many of you who visit here write. Most of you who write choose to write fiction. Almost all of you who visit here read. A lot.

Some of you vary your genre reading, selecting novels purposefully or taking a chance here and there based on somebody’s recommendation. Some of you are precision readers and seek out particular publishers for your reading stock. Some of you read purely for enjoyment and to be entertained. For others, your reading constitutes either a learning or an examination experience.

Sometimes I’ve failed to remember certain novels are supposed to be formulaic. Category romance, historical romance, a lot of romance novels tend to require adhering to a basic formula. Suspense and mystery can also follow a specific formula. I’m fairly sure it depends a lot upon the particular publishing house or their acquisition editors. Nevertheless, when you pick up certain kinds of books, you expect a bit of “formula”.

Where formula goes bad for me is when I know the result in the first few chapters and I no longer care how it goes down. Know what I mean? It’s when the writing itself is safe and too orderly so that not only is the story formulaic but the writing style is, too, I rebel. And strain to finish the book. Unhappy. Blasé about how it all happens.

How ‘bout you?

God, I just want to do what you want me to do. It shouldn’t be that hard, but it often is. I’m sorry for that. Continue to direct my steps, Lord. You know where I need to go and how I need to get there. In the Name of Jesus, Amen.

Posted in

4 responses to “50/50”

  1. Kristen Torres-Toro Avatar

    Hey, Nicole!
    Most of the books I read are based on if I’ve read the author before. I love Amazon’s “books you might like” page. I usually find a book in that pile I’ve never heard of and order that as well. I’ll pick up a women’s fiction over other genres any day unless I recognize/love the other author. But I do read across the board. As for writing, I like to create my own formula–but I love it when formulaic writers do it so well it feels completely new!

    Like

  2. Nicole Avatar

    “As for writing, I like to create my own formula–but I love it when formulaic writers do it so well it feels completely new!” Exactly. Well put.

    Like

  3. Mark H. Avatar
    Mark H.

    I like it when a writer can break the formulas and come up with a new twist on a familiar genre. But I also believe a good writer can take a familiar formula and make it feel new. In a thriller, you might know in the back of your mind that the good guy will win, but a good writer can create doubt in your mind. Or, he/she can twist your expectations within that formula while still delivering the safe landing at the end.
    Like you said, the formula becomes a problem when you as the reader recognize it. You need to be able to surprise the reader. Predictability is death.

    Like

  4. Nicole Avatar

    Also well said, Mark.
    I think it sometimes has a lot to do with the characters themselves, and in the case of thrillers: the kind of action and, as you said, the twists to the familiar.
    It bothers me the most when the writing itself follows a stick-to-the-rules formula because then the whole thing is predictable.

    Like

Leave a reply to Nicole Cancel reply