Into the Fire

Passionate thoughts about the world of writing and the Power of God

Who doesn’t want to write . . .

 

. . . a best-selling novel? Oh I know. The elitist literary crowd loves to insist that exquisite words in dizzyingly unique storytelling won’t draw the “average reader”, which is code for the largely illiterate or unable to recognize excellent writing when they read it. The writing of such rare authors could never appeal to the masses because they (the masses) are too—uh, hey, stupid—to know the value of such profundity as these writers produce. [Not unlike the current government thinks.]

 

But, seriously—as if I wasn’t—some writers recognize their limitations and write to the audience who will support them. Whether or not their publisher’s efforts, or their own, can reach the target readers, these authors know to whom they intend to aim with their novels. Some writers simplify matters by merely desiring to entertain. They don’t make grandiose claims to minister through their pages. They want to tell a story to appeal to X, Y, and Z readers, not necessarily to A, B, and C readers. Some writers want to tackle humor and tickle the funny bones of readers who like quirky, dry wit, or slapstick stories. Others attempt to capture male and female readers with adult tales, suspense, mystery, and thriller novels. Some write only to women. Others primarily for men.

 

Whatever the case, the “success” factor in publishing is spelled out in S A L E S. So let’s not kid ourselves. How thrilled would we be as writers if our novel(s) showed up on the NYT Bestseller List? If we wanted to continue to be published? Very thrilled.

 

Writing as a Christian complicates the matter. Some will argue the point, but it’s truthful that you can’t serve two masters. Jesus made it quite clear. One of those masters will own you. So who will it be? God or . . . ? And who is the one who defines success for you as a writer? God or . . . ? This is tough for a writer. Whether or not it should be, it can be.

 

One form of reasoning is expressed in the philosophy that being “the best” writer one can be, by studying his craft, by adhering to whatever is supposed to make writing “shine”, said writer will attain recognition, publication, abundant sales. Throw in as the add-on that God will be pleased with my hard work and the results of my labor.

 

I would counter that with God will be pleased with the obedience to work hard for Him however He instructs and to be content with the results of your labor whether or not you achieve your interpretation of success. Not always what we want to hear, is it? I mean, c’mon. Is it?

 

Who doesn’t want major sales, some acclaim, some respect from our peers if no one else? We work hard to put together stories. To perfect them—or attempt to do so. So the obvious hope lends itself to interpret success as the standard publishing contract with mucho sales. Right?

 

Or not? What are your thoughts? Or rants?

 

Lord, teach me contentment. Always. Everyday. The real blessing is in following you. In the Name of Jesus, Amen.  

Posted in

6 responses to “***Caution: A bit of a writing rant***”

  1. Robert Liparulo Avatar

    My favorite verse is 2 Chronicles 31:21: “In everything that he undertook in the service of God’s temple and in obedience to the law and the commands, he sought his God and worked wholeheartedly. And so he prospered.” To me, this verse unites human endeavor with God’s sovereignty and providence. Seek God and work hard. Often, we forget one side of that equation. This verse helps me maintain balance, accept His will, and keep things in perspective (usually).
    Great post, Nicole!

    Like

  2. Nicole Avatar

    Wow. Great verse, Robert. Perfect.
    Thanks for dropping by, my friend.

    Like

  3. mike duran Avatar

    Frankly, I tend to equate this argument with the “quality is subjective” one — it can potentially be a smokescreen. I’m not suggesting that’s how you intended it, Nicole, only that by emphasizing “hard work,” “God’s will,” and “letting the chips fall where they may,” we may unintentionally let ourselves off the hook as far as competing in the marketplace. No, I’m not sure “sales” is a good bottom line for Christians. But it is a measurable “line,” and one the industry acknowledges. In any case, Christians should be about quality craft, and like Proverbs 22:29 says, “Do you see a man skilled in his work? He will serve kings.” Yes, we must follow God and let the chips fall where they may. But let’s not forget His promise that by doing things well, there are measurable rewards. Thanks, Nicole!

    Like

  4. Nicole Avatar

    What I’m suggesting, Mike, is this: the mantra that is repeated over and over again in publishing is that really good writing will get published (by a royalty publisher). I disagree. There are too many of us out here–writers, I mean. The literally thousands of queries submitted to agents, etc., indicate the number cannot possibly be effectively examined by anything but personal taste and expectations and projections of what sells. After reading mediocre fiction in abundance, it’s easy to see that the quantifying decisions made by most publishers, and certainly not all, are based on their perceptions of what sells–which can be skewed.
    (Take your speculative fiction as an example. Nearly every person with whom I recently spoke at the NCWR wrote fantasy fiction. Yet CBA continues to resist this genre and insists it’s not a big seller for them. Probably because the readers of Christian fantasy fiction have had to go outside CBA for years to read their pleasure.)
    My point being is there might be some excellent, craft invested writers who will not be wooed by royalty publishers. No matter the quality, the spit shined queries and polished proposals, they will not crack the “code”.
    We so often construe the “rewards” to be monetary and prestigious. As I asked, who doesn’t want to write a bestseller? Who doesn’t want to produce their best work each time they face the keyboard? Who doesn’t wish for the respect of their peers, let alone readers?
    I’m all for hard work and perfecting craft, Mike. But that hasn’t gotten me the “reward” of publishing yet. You can tell me my writing or my efforts are inferior, but I’ve paid my dues. The ultimate result rests in the Lord’s hands.
    Always appreciate your thoughts, Mike.

    Like

  5. mike duran Avatar

    I think we disagree on your central point: “really good writing will get published.” Funny, but that was one of the few adages that I’ve believed in and clung to all these years. It may take a long time, but great writing will eventually be recognized and rewarded. Which is why “perseverance” is the second adage I’ve believed in and clung to. Blessings, Nicole!

    Like

  6. Nicole Avatar

    I guess we do, Mike. I know that “really good writing” does get published. And YaY! for that. But you don’t know anything of the writing that doesn’t get published. Perseverance is key in this business, often more important than talent.
    Perseverance often gets all kinds of writing published, not just “great” writing. But being published in and of itself does not determine that because of it: the author is now a great writer.
    Always blessings to you, too, Mike.

    Like

Leave a reply to Nicole Cancel reply