Into the Fire

Passionate thoughts about the world of writing and the Power of God

 

No. Not anymore. Are you surprised by the so-called trends in publishing? Are you surprised by the rhetoric of individuals in the publishing industry making claims that don’t resonate with what you think, see, hear, and read everywhere on the net or in talking with fellow readers?

 

I don’t hear/read a lot of them because if I took the time to read every professional’s blog who has something informative or of consequence posted, it would be a 24/7 endeavor. And let’s face it: one individual speaks the exact opposite of another many times over. So what’s the point? The point in visiting the many poignant sites on the web is that if you’re new to the writing game, there’s a ton of valuable information to absorb. If you’re so at the beginning of the gig, it’s difficult to apply a custom-made filter. After all, these folks are professionals. Inevitably, if you follow enough of them, you will ask, “What should I believe? What shall I do?” Who wouldn’t? And who hasn’t?

 

I recommend stubbornness. Only because I am. However, it’s not for everyone. Actually, it’s especially not for those who aren’t famous writers. Or for those who might want to become one someday.

 

You see stubbornness refuses to adhere to some of the commonalities of expression which tell us: “Male protagonists are not popular, won’t work, etc., in CBA romance and women’s fiction. Women don’t like to read about men.” Oh really? Just because male protagonists work everywhere else from the general market to television to films, they don’t work in CBA. Let me tell you something: I would prefer to read about men! I’m downright sick of whiny women. Or uppity ladies who think they can outsmart, outwork, and out-do men.   

 

Being stubborn forces you to take a stand. To believe in something enough to proclaim it and stick to it. To rant on like I do about certain elements of publishing that don’t make common sense to this dullard. But, hey, stubbornness means you can count on disagreement, condescension, and at least a few tsks you can’t hear—you sense them more than anything.

 

Why wouldn’t I write about what I like to read? Why wouldn’t I believe in the stories I’ve written? Why wouldn’t I think they have a place in contemporary literature? Not to say they’re all important pieces of work. Not to say they can’t be improved upon. But just to say: I’m not changing them to the point that they don’t resemble my work because what I write isn’t “popular, won’t work, fit, do in CBA”. No.

 

What little phrases raise your ire? How ‘bout: “Speculative fiction doesn’t sell in CBA.” Smirk. That usually starts a discussion . . .

 

Lord, my hope is in you. Period. In the Name of Jesus, Amen.

Posted in

9 responses to “Surprised?”

  1. Brenda Anderson Avatar

    Nicole – I could have written that post myself. 🙂 I think most of what we hear IS true of the CBA market as it stands. BUT that’s failing to take in to account the huge potential market that isn’t tapped. I used to work in our church library & would ask people in our church what they read. 90%+ would never pick up a Christian novel because of the stereotype, so I’d introduce them to the authors who have broken through. If people think the CBA is diverse enough, then they need to look in their local Christian bookstore (or at the recent Christianbook.com fiction catalogue). If you don’t read Amish or Historical, you’ll have a choice, but not much.

    Like

  2. Brenda Anderson Avatar

    I just read a little phrase that perplexes me: “Most people don’t read prologues.” Really? It may be true, but it seems strange. Why would you avoid reading a prologue?

    Like

  3. mike duran Avatar

    Nicole, I believe stubbornness can be incredibly dangerous for an unpublished author. I’m not suggesting that all advice is good, or that a writer must lose their spine to become published. But an aspiring author who is unwilling to listen and be flexible, is one who inevitably calcifies in craft and circles of influence. Again, this is not to suggest a person can’t be opinionated and stubborn and still publish books, but that in this career humility is important. Even now, after I’ve been contracted, I am coming to realize just how much I don’t know about the craft and the business. Digging in my heels is the last thing I need to do. Blessings!

    Like

  4. Nicole Avatar

    Mike, I’m not talking about being “unwilling to listen and be flexible”. I’m talking about the substance of platitudes which don’t reach the audience one seeks in his writing. Did you modify your work to accommodate the prairie romance crowd because of the mantra “Speculative fiction doesn’t sell in CBA.”?
    If you think my statements are arrogant or that I have no humility, I apologize. I am not the least bit secure in my writing craft or my knowledge of the publishing industry, but neither am I impressed by the haughty attitudes and platitudes I’ve heard and witnessed from some members of the industry and in the results of some of what they’ve seen fit to publish, ignoring substantial blocks of readers and making statements which are geared to coveting the same audience they now have and alienating a large unserved group of Christian readers, let alone those who might venture into the realm of reading some worthwhile literature written by CBA authors.
    Always blessings to you as well.

    Like

  5. Nicole Avatar

    Brenda, you and I share the same perspectives. The statements about male protagonists and prologues are just two of the many claims which may or may not apply to a certain group of readers. Prologues are still appearing in CBA novels as you know. The average reader and those of us who appreciate different styles, voices, etc., could care less about novel structures and choices for protagonists. There’s such beauty in variety of creation.

    Like

  6. Brenda Avatar
    Brenda

    Brenda A. said: “If you don’t read Amish or Historical, you’ll have a choice, but not much.”
    I would further expand that by saying if you don’t read romance historical, the choices are virtually nil.
    I have always been completely baffled by the obsession with female protags in CBA fiction.
    You can call it stubborn or not, but every author has to make a choice about how much they are willing to sacrifice the story they want to write. And maybe some people are willing to substantially change their stories to squish into the narrow market. And if that’s their choice, that’s perfectly fine.
    I had to make that choice this summer. I wrote a non-romance historical that was submitted and then rejected because there wasn’t a romance element. That’s perfectly fine. That particular publisher needs romance, I’m not right for them. That’s cool.
    But a fellow writer later asked me “Can’t you put a romance thread in it?” and they seemed incredulous that I didn’t immediately do that. The answer was no–why would I want to do something that would totally change my story? So in the eyes of some, I am labeled “difficult” to work with.
    Well, uh…okay. But since I spend a few thousand hours writing a story, why would I spend all that time writing something I don’t want to read?
    We humans are changing/evolving all the time. Maybe somewhere down the road I will decide I AM willing to substantially change what I want in fiction. But the time is not now. I prefer to bide my time, waiting and writing, and see how the market grows, or if it grows.

    Like

  7. Nicole Avatar

    Brenda (too), I understand. I do. And we can be criticized or called difficult or inflexible, but our only excuse, I guess, is we know what we want to write (and read) and, as you suggested, we’ll wait for the market to change, or we’ll just keep writing until we change . . .

    Like

  8. Melissa Marsh Avatar

    Loved this. I am having to be INCREDIBLY stubborn right now. I’ve had several agents tell me, “World War II doesn’t sell.” HUH? It must be MY kind of WW2 that doesn’t sell – a love story, not a romance.
    I’ve almost reached 100 rejections. Agents who have requested the full and loved it, but ultimately passed, used the excuse of not being able to sell it because of the time period.
    But I refuse, REFUSE, to give up. I’m digging in my heels because I believe in this story with all my heart.

    Like

  9. Nicole Avatar

    Keep believing, Melissa. Can you write another outside this time period while you’re waiting? Love stories as opposed to romance can be universal and timeless. They afford more imagination and latitude in story and time. Just make sure you keep writing while you’re believing for this one. And if WW2 is your era for stories, maybe you could incorporate the current popular methodology of switching back and forth between contemporary and WW2 . . .

    Like

Leave a reply to Brenda Anderson Cancel reply