Into the Fire

Passionate thoughts about the world of writing and the Power of God

 

I’m a Christian who is a writer. I’m a Christian writer. I write fiction. Christian Fiction. It’s a label which incites near cyber-riots but doesn’t bother me at all. If you are a fiction writer who is a Christian, you’ve discerned who your audience most likely is—or will be. Perhaps your fiction is geared to the general market. Or maybe it’s considered “cross-over” because the spiritual aspects of the story are minimal, vague, or imprecise.

 

You’ve been given a desire, a call, a talent, an intention to write stories. And while it may not be heart surgery, writing fiction has value because God doles out the tendencies and enables you to put words together. Anything that the Lord assigns to you is important, purposeful. If you follow His lead, He goes before you to make your path straight. That path might seem rocky, sometimes hidden, and anything but straight, but it’s clear to Him.

 

So why all the fuss? Why the competitive rhetoric about who writes what?

 

The Christian Fiction labeling presents a genuine problem when those authors who write it can only be found in the “Religious” or “Inspirational” areas of secular bookstores. Many of the thriller writers’ books written by Christians could easily be placed in with the general market books, but most of the time they’re not. Publishers have worked hard to correct this but with little success.

 

I don’t blame authors for their frustrations when it comes to proper book placement. Every published author has a lot riding on reaching their audience. If a novel that doesn’t directly deal with faith issues is stuck in the “inspirational” section, an entire possible audience is un-reached and it can be problematic for sales.

 

Here’s the thing for me. I’m firmly convinced no matter how much marketing is done—or not—our dependence (as Christian writers) is on the Lord. Does that imply we sit back and claim our faith will sell our books? Not in this post. It means that authors knock themselves out in all kinds of efforts to market their work and achieve both major sales and major flops. Good writers who’ve been given contracts for multiple books get dropped because of sales and find themselves back at square one—those that excel at marketing and those that don’t. Hired and fired.

 

There are no guarantees. Period. It’s a tough business. How does a particular novel stand out from shelves and shelves of all kinds of books? What difference does it really make what we call ourselves? Or the labels ultimately attached to our work?

 

Some unbelievers might be moved forward spiritually by a “crossover” novel, but that’s not dependent on the writing. It’s dependent upon the Holy Spirit. Apart from Him, we can do nothing. He’s the One who gives the callings, the talents, the gifts, the opportunities. We follow His lead. He defines us. He designs the paths and urges us to stay with Him. In Him we live and have our being.

 

Do you know who you are in the world of writing? Does it really bother you to be defined as a Christian writer?

 

 

Father, may I honor you in all I do. I fall so short, but, Jesus, you’re all I’m livin’ for. In the Name of Jesus, Amen. 

Posted in

12 responses to “Knowing who you are . . .”

  1. Brenda Jackson Avatar

    It doesn’t bother me to be defined as a Christian writer and it doesn’t bother me that inspirational fiction is in the inspirational fiction section. And while bookstores will certainly be around for a while (I hope always), I’m not fretting too much about people finding the books.
    If the book is good enough, word will get out, no matter where it is on the shelves.

    Like

  2. Brenda Anderson Avatar

    I’m not afraid of the Christian Writer or Christian Fiction or Inspirational Fiction labels. They are what they are. I wouldn’t mind stretching the boundaries of those labels though.

    Like

  3. Nicole Avatar

    “If the book is good enough, word will get out, no matter where it is on the shelves.”
    I will take exception to this, Brenda, with no disrespect or offense intended. In secular/general market bookstores the CBA fiction inventory is rather small, carrying an overload of Karen Kingsbury and Ted Dekker novels. All that means is there are many authors who go unrepresented in that venue.
    Regarding “if the book is good enough”, I can think of two authors off the top of my head who were very good writers in the mystery/suspense vein – John Robinson and his Joe Box Mysteries and Sara Mills with her Miss Fortune books – who were dropped after minimal success. There was a third novel in the Miss Fortune series that never got published. Good writers in their genres. Great stories. I think their books are out-of-print now. “Good” is subjective and defined by publishers and held hostage by sales.
    This is where the God-factor applies. I don’t know why their novels didn’t do well when others which, in my opinion, were inferior in writing and story still exist and their authors are still shoveling out more of the same.

    Like

  4. Nicole Avatar

    I so agree, Brenda A.

    Like

  5. Jerri L Ledford Avatar

    I’m going to try to stay off my soapbox here, but still make a point. Nicole, I do believe that God leads writers who are committed to Him to write the things He wants written. And I believe He has a hand in the success or lack of success for some Christian-based books.
    But let’s remember that our God is a God of free will. He allows us to make choices and then uses those choices for his glory.
    That being said, authors are just people. Acquisitions editors are just people. Publishers are run by people. And all of these people represent only a handful of the actual readers that are on the planet. Unfortunately, this small group of people control what books are available to readers.
    It’s like having a favorite food here in the United States. You can say this is your all-time favorite food, but only because you haven’t been exposed to foods from other countries and given the choice to decide if you like American or something else better.
    I believe that many very talented authors with amazing stories are left standing in the shadows because their books don’t “fit” what a publisher defines as a profitable title. When in fact, if the title were given a fair shot, with equal amounts of shelf space, it might actually outsell other “proven” titles.
    Does that mean God didn’t want the book to succeed? I don’t think so. I think it just means that people’s choices mean he’ll find another way to make it reach the people who need it.
    It IS in God’s hands, but don’t forget the “Free Will” factor. People make mistakes all the time. God made us that way, and he loves us that way.

    Like

  6. Nicole Avatar

    Jerri, thanks for your thoughts. I’m not ignoring “free will”. And God knows exactly how many mistakes I’ve made–too many. And still He redeemed and redeems me.
    “I believe that many very talented authors with amazing stories are left standing in the shadows because their books don’t ‘fit’ what a publisher defines as a profitable title. When in fact, if the title were given a fair shot, with equal amounts of shelf space, it might actually outsell other ‘proven’ titles.” I couldn’t agree more with these statements. I think our ideas of “success” are often skewed. But in this business if we want the conventional success, we must adhere to those people who hold the keys, who place value on our work. It’s just the way it’s done. Nothing really wrong with it except for its limited growth.
    People experience things for their spiritual growth. How do we handle rejections? How do we treat others who won’t let us in the door? Do we ultimately trust God to work together for good what we experience along the way? It’s not always about making mistakes or failing. It’s about how we lose ourselves in Jesus. And that’s ours to choose or not.
    Thanks again for your meaningful comments, Jerri. You can get on your soapbox here anytime you want.

    Like

  7. dayle Avatar

    A little off the main topic, but if an author doesn’t want their book in the inspy or Christian fiction section at the book store, then don’t pitch to Bethany House, etc.
    I think these sections help writers who are writing to that market. If the section didn’t exist, the buyer would be lost in the wilderness of secular house books.

    Like

  8. Nicole Avatar

    True, Dayle. I think the small presses have a particular advantage right now–providing their criteria for publication is more flexible than traditional CBA publishers. And it seems the ones who object the most about placement are those in the thriller division and some of those are published by Thomas Nelson and Revell.

    Like

  9. Tim George Avatar

    Randy Singer once reminded me, “The God of the pen is the God of the publishers.” Admittedly, some publishers can seem a little soul-less at times but …. 🙂
    Randy was right. I don’t have a large platform. I am a guy passing middle age, with a small circle of friends, and limited by both finances and health. But my God is not limited. I choose to write my best, encourage others to do the same, use the abilities I have to further my writing career, and leave the rest in God’s hands.

    Like

  10. Nicole Avatar

    Exactly, Tim. That’s it. Thank you.

    Like

  11. Brenda Jackson Avatar

    RE: Not having inspirational fiction in the inspirational section–are not the primary buyers of CBA fiction already Christians? I mean I honestly don’t know how the percentage breaks down of those who are already Christians and those who are just shopping. And I can certainly understand and do value getting fiction into the hands of the lost and seeking.
    But the flip side of that is–interspersing CBA fiction with the general market also means the potential of losing the established readers. Yes, sure, I’m able to spot Kingsbury on the shelf because I’ve seen this author’s name a thousand times. But I WON’T know where to look for new and emerging authors whose names I don’t yet know and I don’t have the time to search.
    As we’ve talked about here previously, people read CBA fic for different reasons–some for the specifically Christian angle, some for the fact that the content has a certain standard (ie. you won’t end up with erotica or whatever).
    While making the inspirational fiction section disappear and merge into the general market shelves may be good for some, it isn’t good for all.
    And while I haven’t seen any data one way or the other, I’m not convinced that dispersing titles is some automatic in for greater sales numbers and writer recognition. But maybe everybody else’s shopping methods are vastly different than mine.

    Like

  12. Nicole Avatar

    I agree, Brenda, as far as the bulk of Christian Fiction. Having a central location directs believers to a specific target area. However, there are some authors of CBA fiction who legitimately belong in the genre sections of thrillers, mysteries, etc. Robert Liparulo, Tim Downs’ the Bug Man novels, Steven James, some of James Scott Bell’s, and even J. Mark Bertrand’s Back on Murder, all would do well in both sections. I would rather they title the section Christian Fiction over “Religious” or “Inspirational” unless they follow the inspirational title with fiction. Otherwise it implies non-fiction titles (at least to me).
    The one point no one usually addresses is the outrage some readers feel at being “tricked” into buying a “religious” book. They’re hardly “tricked” if they can read back cover copy, but I’m sure there would be some who would take the books back (after reading them of course) and complain about it being “religious” in their general market sections. Small number I imagine, but what retailer wants that extra headache?

    Like

Leave a reply to dayle Cancel reply