Into the Fire

Passionate thoughts about the world of writing and the Power of God

 

             
Graphics-agenda-603334

                        

 

When unbelievers in Christianity "happen" upon a Christian novel, some of them accuse the author of having an agenda. They proceed to criticize, mock, or generally degrade the story, plot, and message because to them it smacks of propagandizing fiction. Writers know authors are capable of this in both novels and films, but somehow the agenda is ignored by unbelievers if it's a secular message – especially if it agrees with the reader's own agenda.

Funny how believers can overlook the humanistic and/or politically correct message/agenda in a novel or film if the book or movie is well done, interesting, or captivating story-wise. Not so with many unbelievers reading or viewing Christian fiction or film. Believers are far more likely to be unforgiving to their own (i.e. My Stubborn Heart by Becky Wade).

I would agree that some Christian fiction forces an agenda within their storylines. The over-explaining of Christian reasoning and sermonettes within a story dictate just how an author wants his audience to understand doctrinal goings-on in what constitutes the author's version of a Christian lifestyle. However, the mere mention of Jesus or the establishing of a Christian character can cause some unbelievers to rant about the "religious" inclusions in the story as if this shouldn't be allowed as a part of literature. Novels are given one-star reviews on Amazon because there is a Christian element in the story, obviously foiling the enjoyment for the specific reader. [As a side note, I find it baffling how these particular readers stumble upon reading a Christian novel in the first place since most every one of them alludes to the "religious" content in the back cover copy.]

We know from the words of Jesus that if "they" hated Him, they will certainly hate us as well. We know we tend to be the "underdog" in fiction, that we have our "own" fan base, that proportionately we produce "bad" literature just like the general market does, and that Christianity can be an offense to the world. Well-written or ill-written, if a reader holds a grudge against his perception of Christianity, one mention of Jesus might put him over the edge if he is somehow "tricked" into reading a Christian novel. The mindset of Christian novelists who wish to reach the world with their fiction must pray the Holy Spirit is actively pursuing the hearts of their projected and targeted audience.

I contend that many Christian authors present an option in their fiction. Both worldly and Christian characters make up the body of most books. Contrasts, differences, and similarities of struggles are written into the story. Empathy is coaxed for characters, emotional investment elicited, and outcomes vary according to life choices and those unseen elements which sometimes can't be easily explained. Hope, fear, failure, and all kinds of imaginative circumstances contribute to a character's resolve and the way the story ends. With no specific agenda other than presenting an option of how to approach life on planet earth. With or without the Lord. The ultimate choice for us all.


10596272-your-choice-road-sign

 

Father, our desire is you. Help us to honor you in our writing. You're all we're livin' for. In the Name of Jesus, Amen.

Posted in

8 responses to “Forcing an Agenda or Presenting an Option?”

  1. BK Jackson Avatar

    Maybe I’m forgetting an example but I don’t ever remember reading a novel in Christian fiction that didn’t have both worldly and Christian characters. Unless it was the most unique storyline ever (like all set at a convent or something), no one could realistically NOT have worldly characters. Talk about not being able to suspend disbelief….

    Like

  2. Nicole Avatar

    I don’t recall any. The point being if both worldly and Christian characters are in a story, there should be two contrasting POVs and actions. But those unbelievers who read them and resent the Christian POV generally degrade the story BECAUSE there is a Christian element.

    Like

  3. BK Jackson Avatar

    They can suck it up and deal with it.

    Like

  4. Nicole Avatar

    Some do. However, the types who want the 9/11 surviving metal cross excluded from the tragedy remains because they’re “offended” and it makes them physically ill with headaches, etc., write the one-stars BECAUSE of Christian elements.

    Like

  5. Karin Kaufman Avatar

    Nicole, as you noted, it’s the mere mention of God or (gasp) Jesus that causes readers of secular fiction to say there’s an agenda. There doesn’t have to be any propoganda, any force feeding — just the mention of God and some people’s hackles go up. You must exclude mention of the Creator of all things in order to achieve agenda-less status with these people.
    What I find weird is characters who don’t mention God, even in extreme circumstances (such as impending death), when the normal person’s mind would turn, for at least a moment, to God.
    As for those 1-star reviews, I’m convinced most of them are phony — deliberate plants by people who hate Christian fiction, Christians, God, or all of the above. There’s even a tag on Amazon titled “Christian crap” that anti-Christian trolls use frequently. A new tag, “More Christian crap,” has appeared too.

    Like

  6. Nicole Avatar

    Wow. Sad commentary on the state of readers, huh? If I was more hateful, I’d probably start a tag called “Atheist crap” or “More political crap”, but really I’m not hateful of them but of their “muse”, the enemy of our souls.
    And you’ve hit on the one reason I didn’t like the Tom Hanks’ film Castaway. Not one mention of God or a single prayer by anyone involved in the tragedy. While well-acted (of course), it felt empty, and it was. I cried when the volleyball got away. Yeah, I’m a sap. And when, rightfully, Helen Hunt’s character returned to her home and family. “You were the love of my life” gets me everytime. Sigh.

    Like

  7. Maxine Avatar

    So we are to believe that secular writing doesn’t have an agenda? That is an Inconvenient Truth! Honesty, morality, true-blue, old-fashioned goodness and human kindness seem to have gone the way of the dodo bird in novels, movies, television, and, sadly, in everyday life. Please let’s keep writing of God, prayer, and characters with integrity. It’s all we’ve got left.

    Like

  8. Nicole Avatar

    Exactly, Maxine. Great points. Thanks for stopping by and taking the time to comment.

    Like

Leave a reply to Karin Kaufman Cancel reply