Into the Fire

Passionate thoughts about the world of writing and the Power of God

                      565376-topic-ix-0

Christian fiction writers preach "No preaching". We've all heard – or said – "Nobody wants to be preached at (or to) while reading a story." "Show don't tell." There are many readers in the general market who write apoplectic one-star reviews on Amazon after "mistakenly" reading a Christian novel. At the mere mention of God or Jesus, all hell breaks loose from these people. With accusations of religious drivel ruining the story or wielding rants about being preached at/to, some secular readers want no part of "Christian Fiction".

Some authors who are Christians dance around the label and refuse to see themselves as writing "Christian Fiction". Others desire to attempt the "crossover" route, appealing to the lost instead of "preaching to the choir". Some writers insist the portrayal of Christian principles in stories will serve as a lead-in to seeking salvation or God in general.

The paradox comes in wanting to reach the lost but needing to share the gospel. A Christian can't forfeit who he is in his heart. "Principles" don't necessarily point to God. And the lost won't be interested in Jesus unless the Holy Spirit has been preparing their hearts to recognize the good news.

Christian authors vary in not only their abilities to effectively insert the gospel into stories but in how they manage to make a way for God to be included. Some do it better than others, are far less preachy and much more organic in their approach. However, no matter how well a story is written, if an unbeliever "happens" upon it with no openness in his heart to accept a plot or characters which include Christian elements, the novel will be unfinished, trashed, or at a minimum roust complaints.

Christian Fiction has many stigmas attached to it, some earned and some ridiculously false. Some magnificent writers have constructed meaningful, award winning prose with a Christian message.

As a Christian author, I must tell the story God has planted in my heart. If He wants a major role in that story, He shall have it. If He wants a more subtle presence in the story, He shall have that. I'll do my best to write what He wants me to write, but in the end it's no doubt going to be "Christian Fiction" because that's the world where I live.

 

God, you're it. Everything. All in all. The works. Thank you, Jesus. Holy Spirit, fill me up with everything I need. In the Name of Jesus, Amen.  

   

  

Posted in

3 responses to “The Paradox of Christian Fiction . . .”

  1. BK Jackson Avatar
    BK Jackson

    This is a hard issue. At least for me, the stories I write are me trying to survive by puzzling life out on paper. I struggle with trying to relate the God of the Bible to the here-and-now God. As a result, as with life, it’s all I can do to get the characters (and myself) through another situation or life element without worrying about how someone assesses the “God Level” of my books.
    And honestly, I don’t see how anyone can write Christian fiction and have each story contain the same spiritual element each time. If they can, and its a reflection of the author’s life in some sense, they must have the smoothest spiritual sailing there is to be found. That’s a life I don’t know anything about.
    I think by the time it’s all said and done, I will have books all over the spectrum–some that barely mention God, because He’s not a known part of that character’s life. There will be other books where the spiritual intensity will be high and several in between those two. And that goes back to what you mentioned a few posts back—no author is going to connect with every reader.
    Seems to me that’s the main reason to stick to just telling your story, and let the spiritual elements work themselves out naturally.

    Like

  2. Brenda Anderson Avatar

    Well said, Nicole & Brenda J.
    The level of preachiness is going to depend on the story and the reader. I’m hoping I take an organic approach to writing, that the faith contained within the stories comes across authentic, and if that’s too preachy for some, so be it.
    I really think whether it’s preachy or not is going to depend upon how God is working in the readers’ hearts at the time. He can make Himself known in subtle or billboard ways.

    Like

  3. Nicole Avatar

    Good talking points, Ladies. Strip it down, and it’s all about what God has in mind for us as writers and for each individual reader . . .

    Like

Leave a reply to Nicole Cancel reply