Into the Fire

Passionate thoughts about the world of writing and the Power of God

  Blue bloods s3

I'm a huge fan of Tom Selleck, and I've enjoyed his latest series Blue Bloods. A family of cops, two New York Police Commissioners in the retired grandfather and father (Frank Reagan, played by Tom Selleck), one son (and brother) has died in the line of duty and Tom Selleck's wife has passed away when the series begins.

But seemingly with all series TV, there comes a season where the characters "devolve" and the writing suffers. That would be this year for Blue Bloods. This season the Police Commissioner played by Selleck has become more hard-hearted and less empathetic. The worst episode of the season, and perhaps the series, aired Friday evening (March 13th).

A young bride-to-be enlists the PC to walk her down the aisle of her wedding because many years ago he was the investigating officer of her family's disturbing murder, and she describes him as like a father to her. She is so important to him that he allows her to show up at his office and immediately gain entrance to talk to him whereas anyone else, including his staff, must keep specific appointments with him.

She receives a letter from the incarcerated murderer but doesn't open it instead bringing it to the PC to read. When he encourages her to wait until after her marriage to make a decision whether or not she wishes to learn its content, she makes the decision to ask what he's written. When the PC tells her the murderer wants to see her to make amends, she goes to the prison with the PC – she with a huge mad on and he with utter disdain and cynicism. To this point, she's a sympathetic character, and we understand the Commissioner's opinion and attitude.

However, the spectacle of the murderer's confession and her reaction to him reverses the sympathy for her. She is hateful, bitter, ugly, and by her own words will never forgive him. While it would've been acceptable for her not to indulge in trusting his confession, the demonstration of skepticism without the putrid outburst and cruel venomous response would have been far more beneficial to view. And all the while, the PC nods his head at her, urging her to get it all out. It's an ugly scene, and totally eliminated any sympathy or empathy I held for her. The Commissioner tells her he's proud of her, and I felt like gagging.

There have been traces of God-mocking in the PC's character, but the portrayal and endorsement of this young woman's ungodly behavior makes me wonder about the "hidden" agenda of Blue Bloods. If these subtle – and not so subtle – examples continue to be held up within the episodes, perhaps assuming this Catholic family's Sunday dinners around the table after saying "grace" will be enough to sustain viewers such as myself, I'm one viewer they can count on losing. Who needs it?

 

Father, it's almost impossible to forgive those who've done horrendous things to us or our families. You're the only one who can help us forgive, and forgive we must. It never means forget. It means forgive. Your ways are so much higher than our own. We struggle to understand them and to do the right things. Please forgive us for indulging sin in so many ways. We're all desperate for you. In the Name of Jesus, Amen. 

Related articles

Selleck defends 'Blue Bloods'
Posted in

7 responses to “The worst episode . . .”

  1. BK Jackson Avatar
    BK Jackson

    “there comes a season where the characters “devolve” and the writing suffers.”
    I’ve never watched Blue Bloods but that succinctly describes Season 5 of Hawaii Five-0.

    Like

  2. Nicole Avatar

    Honestly, I don’t know why it happens. I mean, I can understand it if there are major cast changes – important actors leave a series – but when it’s basically the same characters, I don’t get it. If the producers/writers, etc., can keep a series interesting for three or four seasons, what happens to their concepts for the next season(s)? Why take a “good” character and deteriorate his overall persona? Don’t get that.

    Like

  3. BK Jackson Avatar
    BK Jackson

    I’ve wished many times I could get my hands on Peter Lenkov from Hawaii Five-0, shake him and ask him what the devil he thinks he’s doing. It’s hard when you watch a great series and then the powers that be turn it into a complete disaster. What a waste.

    Like

  4. Nicole Avatar

    Facebook them. A lot of them (series) have a presence there. Post your criticisms/critiques. Make a statement. You’ll probably find you have those who agree with you.

    Like

  5. Brenda Anderson Avatar

    Sorry I’m late responding. I had to get my son back to school (8 hours in the car yesterday) so he can head to Seattle for the NCAA Tournament. 🙂
    Blue Bloods is probably my favorite show on TV. There have been a couple episodes I didn’t care for, but for the most part, I’ve really enjoyed it.
    As for last Friday’s episode, it was very disconcerting. But, it also helped initiate discussion in our family. We talked about being in the position the guest character was in–hopefully we wouldn’t make the same choice she did, but I pray I’ll never know for certain. Still, I think what she said was realistic, unfortunately. Did Frank’s character remain true to himself? Actually, I think he did. As the PC, he’s likely very unforgiving about events like that. Did I like his reaction? Not at all! But I think it remained in character for him.
    And you’re right about her; her choice did take away any sympathy or empathy. Perhaps it made me pity her because she would be living a very bitter life. Can you imagine harboring that hate for forever?Forgiveness isn’t about letting the other person off the hook, which was what she believed, but it’s about freeing ourselves.

    Like

  6. Brenda Anderson Avatar

    After reading your post I had to go to the Blue Bloods Facebook page to see what viewers were saying. Most of the talk was about the Jaime / Eddie storyline, which was very good, but there were also a few very good comments about Frank’s storyline. One talked about how “Sarah” became as much of a monster as the man who killed her family. Interesting perspective.
    Another person reminded me that Baker (Frank’s assistant) had a completely different point of view.
    Anyway, you’re not the only one troubled by the episode.

    Like

  7. Nicole Avatar

    Cool your son gets to come out this way!
    It’s good to hear that other viewers agreed with me – it’s a vote for common decency if you want to observe it outside of the spiritual factor.
    I agree in light of this year’s particular characterization of Frank Reagan he would’ve approved of her stand against this murderer. And, yeah, Baker obviously had a decent opinion on the matter. And, yeah, if we want to indulge our flesh and let it out bare naked, the young bride-to-be expressed realistic hatred for the man who brutally killed her family. Exposed: it’s ugly as the murder.

    Like

Leave a reply to BK Jackson Cancel reply