Into the Fire

Passionate thoughts about the world of writing and the Power of God

          Bookstoresign_christianfiction

                     This is from an old post written in 2018. 

A Double Standard?

Have you established criteria for what you expect to find when reading Christian fiction? I think it’s safe to say many readers do so. The expectations vary according to the genres, but they also vary based on readers’ favorite authors and a formulated general standard assessed by individual readers. “Standards” which often result in requirements by these readers. Standards which when not met cause the complaints we discussed not too long ago here.

I know some of us who read a Christian novel by an author we’ve never sampled hope to find an organic approach to spiritual occurrences. There aren’t any requirements necessary other than an authentic approach to any faith elements within the story including those addressing the unseen factors when they materialize into the physical realm. (A note here to fantasy fans: I’m not discussing your genre here.)

What I don’t want to experience in a supposedly Christian novel are token Christians whose faith is marginal at best spouting Christian-ese and uttering quick prayers in crisis. I guess you could say this is a requirement for my reading pleasure.

Christianity demands a certain boldness. However, that boldness shows itself in so many variations because our Creator doesn’t use monochrome in designing his characters (us). We can see ourselves in others, but dissected we’re different. We can share similar emotions, desires, talents, and skills, but somewhere our individualism will separate us and make us unique. That unique approach to portraying Christianity in literature is what can make a story sterling, satisfying, even superb.

So are you as tough on general market fiction as you are on Christian fiction? Do you apply a double standard to your assessments?

 

Lord, may we write as you have gifted us, being obedient to what you set before us. May we listen and be directed by your Spirit and no one else. In the Name of Jesus, Amen.

Posted in

5 responses to “An old question . . .”

  1. Brenda S. Anderson Avatar

    I’m probably tougher on Christian fiction than I am on the general market. 😀

    Like

  2. Nicole Petrino-Salter Avatar

    You and me both. Where I definitely don’t apply a double standard is in the writing. You find excellence in both markets and marginal at best in both markets. I guess because I expect authenticity from a Christian author, I’m quite hard on a work that feeds that “typical”, “canned”, “complacent”, and/or “cliched” writing, plot, story.

    Like

  3. Brenda S. Anderson Avatar

    Yes, it’s the authenticity in CF that bothers me, so I love that readers appreciate my true-to-life stories.

    Like

  4. Nicole Petrino-Salter Avatar

    Yes, you take all kinds of characters and situations, Bren, and you put those characters in hard places. Sometimes they have to grind it out before they get to the right results. It’s not fake.
    Honestly, romance is a difficult genre at times. Especially in CF. I’ve given up attracting the base CF audiences – they don’t seem to like the authenticity that doesn’t adhere to their strict experiences of having grown up in the church and never veered away from staunch – some legalistic – conduct.

    Like

  5. Brenda S. Anderson Avatar

    The same goes for me with women’s fiction.

    Like

Leave a reply to Brenda S. Anderson Cancel reply