Into the Fire

Passionate thoughts about the world of writing and the Power of God

More than one of the conversations I had with different individuals at the conference was the ongoing claim of those professing not to read much Christian fiction because it’s β€œfluff”. Well, nothing stops me in my tracks faster and gets me going in a straight line to challenge their claims. And though I’m not in any way keeping score, I inevitably β€œwin” those conversations and have the naysayers quickly writing down the slew of names of Christian fiction authors they’ve never heard of that I’m recommending to them. The truth be known they don’t know enough about Christian fiction to make those erroneous statements. Yes, they’ve probably slogged through a couple of mediocre novels and assumed the entire bunch must be the same. Simply not true.

Since I write Christian fiction, I get defensive at those patronizing writers who make the bold statements about how, yes, β€œedgy” their writing is and how it doesn’t fit into the CBA mold. Well, guess what? It might not fit into the Love Inspired imprint or even at Bethany House, but I guarantee if it’s not trash, there’s a Christian publisher out there who will consider it. The borders are open in a lot of houses, and you don’t even have to show your passport.

I can just imagine the next summons saying, β€œDefine β€˜trash’”. Look, I’m not going to go so far as to say erotica and f-bombs are acceptable to Christian publishers. However, if your work must include graphics in words or sexual intercourse, then you want to try the general market (ABA) anyway. Or custom publish your work.

But don’t try to tell me that the reality of β€œthe world” is being left out of Christian fiction. It is certainly not. And there are some absolutely amazing writers putting together phenomenal stories distributed by major Christian publishers. Some of those publishers (Hachette Book Group’s Faith Words and Center Street divisions and Thomas Nelson for another) are publishing novels which stretch what are considered β€œsafe” boundaries by others.

And if you think every Christian novel must declare the gospel or record a salvation experience, you are so behind the times in your Christian novel reading. There are myriad stories out there in Christian publishing where there is virtually no mention of Jesus Christ, no characters who exhibit lifelike Christian qualities or principles, and even the Christian worldview is vague at best.

Quality writing is there in Christian novels. You just have to know what you like and who fits into your ideals. Once you can qualify your preferences, I’m willing to bet the books are there for you. And if they aren’t, they’re on the way because there are houses in the industry trying to get outside the status quo.

Father, thank you for each writer who strains to write for you, to honor you with all they do. Thank you for pure hearts who strive to give their best in all things that you might receive the glory and praise due to you alone. In the Name of Jesus, Amen.

Posted in

12 responses to “Defensive”

  1. Robert Liparulo Avatar

    Here, here, Nicole! I can always count on you for an honest, insightful appraisal. You go, girl! How’d the conference go? How were your meetings?

    Like

  2. Nicole Avatar

    Thanks, Robert. Always appreciate you. I sent you an email. Let me say it one word: ironic.

    Like

  3. dayle Avatar

    I had to assure a member of my writing group yesterday that Christian fiction has come a long way since the ’80s.
    If anyone thinks Tosca Lee, Robert L., Athol Dickson, Charles Martin, Dayle Arceneaux :), etc. writes inferior novels then they simply haven’t read them.

    Like

  4. Nicole Avatar

    Amen to that, Dayle. Nice of you to include yours truly. Dang.

    Like

  5. dayle Avatar

    Well, I didn’t want to be accused of pandering.
    Everybody already knows I have a healthy ego sometimes called delusional, so no harm in including myself.

    Like

  6. Nicole Avatar

    Absolutely no harm in including yourself. It’s my unhealthy ego you smarted, big guy. πŸ˜‰

    Like

  7. David Murdoch Avatar

    My novel had a lot about salvation, Jesus Christ and a christian worldview and I thought it was good.
    I think that any literature which is meant to bring people closer to Christ is good, although I don’t know if someone necessarily needs to mention salvation or a christian worldview in order to do this.
    Thank you for your prayer,
    God Bless,

    Like

  8. cindy Avatar

    While I don’t agree that so many books containing nearly no Christian worldview are still considered Christian, I do agree that there is a plethora of good writing out there that isn’t “fluff”.
    I can think of a handful of “edgy” writers out there who not only insert a non-preachy but effective echo of their beliefs in their novels but also tell a really well written story that in no way glosses over the realities of the “real” world.
    Thanks for the interesting post.

    Like

  9. Nicole Avatar

    David, I would agree. And I certainly think the well-written implementation of the gospel in a story speaks of the true reality more than anything else. It’s specifically how organically it springs from the story, how intense the characters face their struggles and tackle the trials of life which bodes well for spiritual themes and makes the novel effective. It most certainly can be done well and is by several authors.

    Like

  10. Nicole Avatar

    Cindy, I wouldn’t necessarily put the “Christian” novel attachment to them either even though a Christian author has written them or a Christian publisher has produced them. I know the efforts of many authors who are Christians that write with a vague Christian worldview believe many other Christian authors are “preaching to the choir” and ignoring the lost by including themes and stories which are too spiritual. However, The Shack kind of blows that reasoning out of the water since it’s basically one long sermon of a story. Whether or not a person agrees with the God-concepts, this is a novel which has reached a multitude of people, believers and non-believers. And it couldn’t be more “preachy”.
    I agree there are many “edgy” writers in our ranks now who include the gospel–or not–by writing effective stories with realistic plots and characters.

    Like

  11. Mike Duran Avatar

    I appreciate your passion, Nicole. While I agree that the quality issue is bogus, the “edgy” issue is not. You suggested that if an author “must include graphics in words or sexual intercourse” they should go ABA. But that’s exactly where some of the CBA objectors find fault. Sure, “…if it’s not trash, there’s a Christian publisher out there who will consider it.” Nevertheless, if it doesn’t pass the the CBA censors and strictures, it’s not published as Christian fiction. So it’s not the “quality / lack of quality” issue that bothers me. It’s the narrowing of the boundaries that force Christian authors outside the camp. Blessings!

    Like

  12. Nicole Avatar

    Likewise, I appreciate your well-articulated passion, Mike. It does seem to me that those authors who wish to include erotica or f-bombs have little desire to approach CBA publishers, but perhaps I’m wrong about that. The “less” offensive (than the f-word)words are appearing in some works of the above mentioned publishers’ novels.
    I also think writers with your talent, for example, who have a compelling story with realistic characters can effectively write around most of the language obstacles without turning a story into a squeaky clean prairie romance.
    The “censors and strictures” do vary considerably within the ranks of CBA publishers being considerably expanded with Faith Words and Center Street under Hachette Book Group and within the Thomas Nelson label.
    I think the original objective was to produce faith-based, clean fiction so Christians could have something to read without having to wade through some of the filth out there. Some of it now is just cleaner fiction with a barely discernible worldview.
    The general market bookstore divisions that tuck certain novels in the “inspirational” or “religious” sections are doing themselves and the authors a disservice. Many of those novels would sell better side by side with their counterparts in the industry. I know several CBA publishing house reps have met with Borders, Barnes & Noble reps to discuss changes in shelving their books.
    I sympathize with Christian writers who seem to stand outside the CBA world with the outcast label. Because of the approach and themes of my novels, it’s been suggested to me that they’re too spiritual to be included in ABA consideration and too real in their approach to sexual issues to be included in most CBA considerations. While I understand the objections to the policies, I’ve seen the margins expanding in just the last few years, and I guess I’d rather not see them compromise too much but just enough to allow in those authors who genuinely seek to glorify the Lord with their writing even when it includes a few words or deeds that rock the “acceptable” boat.
    Blessings to you as well, Mike. Always enjoy when you stop by.

    Like

Leave a comment